Thursday, June 28, 2012

Week #3 - Analogy/Homology Blog Post



HOMOLOGOUS TRAIT - INCISORS



BEAVER GNAWING AWAY


THE BEAVER

Beavers, are great builders with powerful jaws and big strong incisors. 
(Please see analogous trait below for more information on the beaver)




ELEPHANT USING TUSKS TO PEEL BARK FROM A TREE; ONE OF MANY USES




ELEPHANTS USING THEIR TUSKS TO FIGHT




THE ELEPHANT

The elephant is the largest land animal currently living. It is a herbivorous mammal with thick almost hairless skin, a long flexible prehensile trunk which they use for a multitude of tasks like drinking, tearing up food and placing it in their mouths, and sucking up water to spray their bodies. They also have upper incisors forming long curved tusks which they use for digging, fighting and peeling bark from trees, as well as large fan-shaped ears.



HOMOLOGOUS TRAIT

The homologous trait shared by the beaver and the elephant is the incisor tooth. An incisor tooth is a sharp-edged tooth in mammals that is adapted for cutting or gnawing. The incisors are located in the front of the mouth between the canine teeth. Although this trait has a similar origin, the structures and functions differ. Beavers use their incisors to knock/cut down and gnaw trees, while elephants use theirs for fighting, digging, and peeling bark from trees to eat. 
Beaver incisors are small, flat, thin, but very strong. They have a hard orange coat that keeps them from breaking and because gnawing wood wears the teeth out, they continue to grow throughout their lifetime. Elephant incisors, also known as tusks, are made of ivory (a hard, smooth, yellowish/white, dentine) which serves as protection. These tusks are rather long and curvy.


COMMON ANCESTOR

The general common ancestor is a mammal. I know that the ancestor possessed this homologous trait because all mammals possess incisor teeth. 






ANALOGOUS TRAIT - WEBBED FEET



BEAVER WEBBED FEET- 5 TOES ALL WEBBED
  
JUST KEEP SWIMMING....
   
YES, UP TO SOMETHING!















THE BEAVER

Beavers, also known as "nature's best architects" are semi-aquatic large rodent mammals. They are nocturnal herbivores who live in colonies near permanent water and woody plants (streams, ponds, small lakes, and marshes). Their life expectancy is 8 to 10 years, they are very territorial and are known to mate for life. Beavers have made adaptations that allow them to live in water. They have powerful jaws and big strong incisors, a flat hairless tail which helps maintain their balance and is also used as a rudder, short front legs with heavy claws, long rear legs with webbed feet which help propel them through water, a thick layer of fat that keeps them warm under water,  naturally oily and waterproof fur, transparent eyelids which help them see under water, and although they cannot breathe under water they have a special respiratory adaptation that allows them to store enough oxygen to swim under it. 

WEBBED FEET - 4 TOES 3 WEBBED
SWIMMING, OH SO GRACEFULLY
UGLY DUCKLING? I DON'T THINK SO!

                      











THE DUCK

The duck is a bird and because it lives in places near water (marshes, ponds, rivers) it is also known as a "waterflow". There are many different types of ducks; dabbling duck, diving duck, perching duck, etc. Ducks have short necks, short wings, a stout body, short legs and webbed feet which they use as paddles to swim. These webbed feet are the reason why they waddle instead of walk. Their mouth, known as their bill, is used to hunt for food. Underneath their waterproof coat, they have fluffy feathers which keep them warm.

ANALOGOUS TRAIT

The analogous trait shared by both the beaver and the duck is webbed feet. Webbed feet is defined as having digits connected by a thin fold of skin; palmate (shaped like an open hand and having 3 toes connected by a web). Both the beaver and the duck use their webbed feet as propellers to swim; this meets the similarity in the function of the trait. Although only 3 of the duck's 4 toes are webbed, as opposed to all 5 of the beaver's toes, there are still similarities in their structure. The toes are claw-like and in between is a stretch of flexible web. 

COMMON ANCESTOR 

In my opinion, the common ancestor (chordata vertebrate) of the beaver and the duck did not possess this analogous trait. These two species have developed webbed feet through parallel evolution not through inheritance. Beavers for example, lived in land, but have made adaptations which enable them to now also live in water. Not all birds are water birds, therefore ducks have also made adaptations.

7 comments:

  1. It is absolutely astounding to find out that the beaver, a small rodent, and the largest living land animal have a common ancestor! I find it interesting to locate homologous traits that can actually prove these mammals are related-it's quite mind blowing actually. I also find it very interesting that the incisors on both animals are located "outward' of the animal. The tusks of the elephant and the buck teeth of the beaver.

    I think baby ducks are by far one of the cutest animals I have ever seen. I really enjoyed how you used the beaver to relate in both scenarios, it made for a continuous flow that was easy to follow. I also think that its interesting that beavers and ducks share the same idea of webbed feet, minus the number of toes being different. I felt this assignment had its challenges because if they share a trait-they must be related somehow! So it was interesting to do some research on the topics and try to locate where they share an ancestor. I did a study on platypuses and beavers. They both share the same trait, their tails for swimming. They have very similar bone structures located in them... AND yet, are different species that are adapting to their environment. The universe is the most confusing, controversial and yet exciting study I have done in a while.

    P.S. I'm always so impressed with your blogs. You spend a lot of time and effort into making a very attractive blog, and it shows :) awesome job!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Carmen,

    First of all, thank you so much for your comment and for your kinds words, extremely nice of you; you made me smile :)
    I have to agree with you, I too was stunned to learn about the elephant and beaver. Additionally, I was impressed by the beaver, they are really cool animals and boy can they build.
    Lastly, I have to be honest, I found this assignment to be a bit challenging, especially the analogous trait, but challenges can have a positive impact. And like you stated, studying about the universe can be so exciting too.

    Thank you,
    Marta

    ReplyDelete
  3. For thinking this assignment was a bit challenge, I interpreted as you took the "bull by the horns" sort of speak. You did a great job and you're examples with the webbed feet as the trait was completely relevant. You really emphasized how you understood the meaning of homologous trait and analogous traits.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Kristina,

      Thank you so much, I greatly appreciate the feedback!!!!

      Delete
  4. I really like the decision to use one common organism for both parts of this assignment (beaver). That drives home how analogous and homologous traits are independent of each other and one individual will carry both types of traits depending upon the comparison organism.

    Very good on the descriptions, images and background on your choices. The only caution is your common ancestor between the beaver (mammal) and the duck (bird). Their common ancestor was a reptile. You don't have to go back to the ancestor of the vertebrates to find their common ancestor. Otherwise, great job.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dear professor, thank you so much for your feedback, always appreciated. For some reason I struggled with the common ancestor and although I thought it was the reptile, I hesitated :(
      Thank you again!
      Marta

      Delete
    2. Thank you for the response, Marta.

      Delete